Privat | Magic the Gathering

Immaculate Magistrate

1
Sep/110

Immaculate Magistrate

rate my elf deck for magic the gathering?

here's a list

ambush commander x2
wellwisher x3
voice of the woods x2
thornweald archer x2
immaculate magistrate x1
lanowar elves x2
nath's elite x1
lys alana bowmaster x1
lys alana huntmaster x3
timberwatch elf x2
allosaurus rider x1
elvish branchbender x1
lanowar mentor x1
wren's run vanquisher x3
wren's Run Packmaster x1
Imperious Perfect x3
winnower patrol x1
jagged scar archers x1
drove of elves x1
rhys the redeemed x1
enchantments intans sorcerys
elvish promenade x3
presence of gond x2
evolution charm x1
lands
19 forest
1 wirewood lodge
1 sapseep forest
this deck is 60 cards tell me what i'm doing wrong

Ok i will be more realistic than the guy above me.
this deck is inconsistent it has no clearly visible strategy, or win condition other than voice of the woods.
(a win condition being a big spell that if caste will probably win you the game, like overwhelm)

lets begin.. you dont have enough land, you need 23-24 land and preferably just normal forests, sapseed is slow(it comes into play tapped) and you dont need it when you have well wishers.
so 24 forests will be your mana base.

ok now these are the cards we are keeping 'cos the list of cardfs that are going, is too long.

wellwisher x4
voice of the woods x2
lanowar elves x4
nath's elite x3
timberwatch elf x4
wren's run vanquisher x4
wren's run packmaster x2
imperious perfect x4

other spells
elvish promenade x4

as you can see ive added more copies of the remaining cards for consistency.
ill explain my choices.
the ambush commander is dangerous to use, if some one uses wrath of god you will lose all of your forests.
allosaurus rider is just bad
and all of the other cards are just unnecissary.

ok now ill make some additions. all easy to obtain and neccissary.

4x wellwisher
2x voice of the woods
4x lanowar elves
3x nath's elite
4x timberwatch elf
4x wren's run vanquisher
4x imperious perfect
-------------------------------

other spells
4x elvish promenade
-----------------------
4x gilt leaf ambush(lorwyn)
2x harmonize(elves vs gobs, or Planar Chaos)

yep that is about it
all you can fit into 60 cards
this deck is efficient consistent and will alow you to win games either by trampling over their faces with the elementals made by voice or by distracting their creatures with nath's elite and bashing face.

m,aking a good deck isn't about cramming in rares it is about making an efficient synergistic mix of cards and bashing face.